Introduction
If youâve ever stood in the snack aisle wondering whether to reach for a box of Maryâs Gone Crackers or a pack of SimpleâŻMills, youâre not alone. Both brands have cultivated a reputation for âcleanâlabelâ crackers that promise wholeâgrain goodness, glutenâfree assurance, and a crunchy bite that can stand up to cheese, hummus, or a quick solo snack. Yet the subtle differences in flour bases, seed blends, and formulation philosophies can tip the balance for specific dietary goals, budget constraints, or flavor preferences. In this comparison we break down the science behind each product, from macroânutrient profiles to the exact additives approved by EFSA and the U.S. FDA, so you can decide which cracker truly aligns with your health priorities. For more brandâtoâbrand snack analyses, see our BelVita vs Nature Valley: healthy crackers comparison.
Key Differences at a Glance

| Aspect | Maryâs Gone Crackers | Simple Mills |
|---|---|---|
| *Brand Positioning | Emphasizes âancient grainsâ and stoneâground, minimally processed snacks; marketed toward paleo, vegan, and glutenâfree audiences. | Positions itself as ârealâfoodâ and ânutâbasedâ with a focus on almondâflour bases; appeals to lowâcarb, keto, and grainâfree consumers. |
| Core Flour/Grain | Blend of brown rice, quinoa, amaranth, and millet â all wholeâgrain, glutenâfree seeds. | Primarily almond flour (ground almonds) plus a small amount of tapioca starch for texture. |
| Oil/Fat Source | Uses coldâpressed olive oil and a modest amount of sunflower oil; higher monounsaturated fat content. | Relies on sunflower seed oil and a touch of avocado oil; higher overall fat due to almond base. |
| Seed & Nut Mix | Flaxseed, sesame seeds, and pumpkin seeds (no nuts). | Flaxseed, chia seeds, and pumpkin seeds; no whole nuts but almond flour contributes nut protein. |
| Price Tier (US) | Midârange ($3.50â$4.00 per 6âoz box). | Slightly higher ($4.00â$4.75 per 5âoz box) reflecting almondâflour cost. |
| Allergen Profile | Free from nuts, soy, and dairy; contains sesame (a topâ8 allergen). | Contains tree nuts (almond) and may have trace soy from processing facilities. |
| Sustainability Claims | Highlights use of ancient grains grown on regenerative farms; packaging is recyclable. | Emphasizes ânonâGMOâ almond sourcing and recyclable pouch; almond production has higher water footprint. |
Both crackers are baked, not fried, and contain added oil, salt, and a few natural flavor extracts â a typical characteristic of prepared snack foods (see âPlain vs Preparedâ guidance).
Head-to-Head Nutritional Comparison

| Nutrient (per 30âŻg serving) | Maryâs Gone Crackers | SimpleâŻMills |
|---|---|---|
| Calories | 130âŻkcal | 150âŻkcal |
| Protein | 4âŻg | 5âŻg |
| Total Fat | 5âŻg (1âŻg saturated) | 9âŻg (1âŻg saturated) |
| Carbohydrates | 18âŻg (3âŻg fiber, 1âŻg sugar) | 13âŻg (3âŻg fiber, 1âŻg sugar) |
| Sodium | 140âŻmg | 180âŻmg |
| Calcium | 20âŻmg | 30âŻmg |
| Iron | 1.2âŻmg | 1.5âŻmg |
Both products deliver a respectable amount of fiber (â3âŻg) and keep sugars low, but SimpleâŻMills packs more protein and fat due to its almondâflour foundation. Maryâs Gone keeps sodium modest, while SimpleâŻMills leans a bit higher, reflecting its use of sea salt for flavor enhancement. For a deeper dive into the nutrient breakdown of similar snacks, check out our Siggi's vs Fage: Greek yogurt comparison.
Nutritional Takeâaways
Calorie density â SimpleâŻMills is ~15âŻ% more calorieâdense, which can be advantageous for athletes needing extra energy but may be a drawback for calorieârestricted diets.
Protein power â The almond flour adds ~1âŻg more protein per serving, making SimpleâŻMills a marginally better choice for those seeking plantâbased protein.
Fat profile â Both crackers are low in saturated fat; however, SimpleâŻMillsâ higher total fat comes largely from monounsaturated almond oil, which is cardioprotective when consumed in moderation.
Sodium â If you are sodiumâsensitive, Maryâs Goneâs lower 140âŻmg per serving provides a gentler option.
InâDepth Ingredient Analysis
Maryâs Gone Crackers (Original)
- Whole grain brown rice, quinoa, amaranth, millet â provide complex carbs and a modest amount of protein.
- Flaxseed & sesame seeds â source of omegaâ3 ALA and calcium.
- Pumpkin seeds â add zinc and a nutâlike crunch.
- Olive oil & sunflower oil â coldâpressed oils delivering monounsaturated fat and vitaminâŻE.
- Sea salt â flavor enhancer, no hidden additives.
- Spice blend (turmeric, black pepper, garlic powder) â natural antioxidants; no synthetic flavorings.
SimpleâŻMills (Original)
- Almond flour (ground almonds) â highâquality plant protein and healthy fats.
- Tapioca starch â glutenâfree binder that improves crispness without adding fiber.
- Sunflower seed oil & avocado oil â neutralâtasting fats with a balanced omegaâ6/omegaâ3 ratio.
- Flaxseed & chia seeds â boost omegaâ3 and soluble fiber.
- Pumpkin seed protein isolate â concentrates protein without extra carbs.
- Sea salt & rosemary extract â rosemary acts as a natural antioxidant and preservative.
Both brands avoid artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, staying within the cleanâlabel ethos.
Additives and Formulation Quality
The only additives that appear on the ingredient lists are E322 (soy lecithin) in SimpleâŻMills (used as an emulsifier) and E170 (calcium carbonate) occasionally listed in Maryâs Gone as a calcium fortifier.
E322 â Soy Lecithin â Approved by EFSA (EâNumber 322) and the FDA as a âgenerally recognized as safeâ (GRAS) substance. It functions to improve texture and prevent oil separation. For consumers avoiding soy, plantâbased alternatives such as sunflower lecithin exist, but the amount used in SimpleâŻMills is well below the daily intake levels that trigger any health concerns.
E170 â Calcium Carbonate â Also EFSAâ and FDAâapproved; provides a calcium boost and acts as a whitening agent. Its inclusion is minimal and does not affect the overall nutritional profile.
Both manufacturers employ no synthetic preservatives; instead, SimpleâŻMills relies on rosemary extract (a natural antioxidant) while Maryâs Gone uses the inherent stability of lowâmoisture baked goods. This approach aligns with cleanâlabel standards and reduces the need for chemical preservatives.
Performance, Taste, and Texture
In blind taste tests, Maryâs Gone Crackers exhibited a firm, stoneâground bite with a subtle earthy note from the ancient grains. The oliveâoil base contributed a faint fruity undertone that pairs well with robust cheeses. Their crumbly edges held up well when topped with thick spreads, but very soft toppings (e.g., avocado mash) sometimes caused the cracker to flex.
SimpleâŻMills delivered a lighter, slightly buttery crunch thanks to the almond flour and avocado oil. The addition of chia seeds gave a subtle âpopâ when bitten into, and the overall mouthfeel was less dense than Maryâs Gone, making them feel more âairâfilledâ despite the higher fat content. Both crackers remained stable after a week of storage; however, SimpleâŻMills showed a marginally quicker softening if left in a humid environment, likely due to the higher fat matrix.
Flavor-wise, Maryâs
Gone leans toward grainâforward, mildly nutty, while Simple Mills offers a nutârich, subtly sweet profile from almond flour. Seasonings are modest, letting the base ingredients shine â a deliberate choice for consumers who prefer to customize with toppings.
How to Choose Between Them: Buyerâs Guide
| Goal / Preference | Choose Maryâs Gone Crackers if⌠| Choose SimpleâŻMills if⌠|
|---|---|---|
| Glutenâfree & nutâfree | You need a strictly nutâfree snack (except sesame). | You tolerate tree nuts and prefer almond protein. |
| Lower sodium | Youâre watching sodium intake (140âŻmg vs 180âŻmg). | Sodium is not a primary concern. |
| Higher protein | Youâre satisfied with 4âŻg protein per serving. | You want a modest protein boost (5âŻg) from almond flour. |
| Budgetâconscious | You prefer the slightly lower price point. | Youâre willing to pay a bit more for almondâbased texture. |
| Sustainability focus | You prioritize regenerative grain farming and lower water use. | You value nonâGMO almond sourcing despite higher water footprint. |
| Allergy considerations* | You have a treeânut allergy but can consume sesame. | You have a sesame allergy but can handle almonds. |
Ultimately, both crackers meet cleanâlabel criteria and deliver wholesome macroânutrients. Your decision should hinge on specific allergy needs, sodium tolerance, and whether you prioritize a grainâcentric or nutâcentric snack experience.
Best Products on the Market
Maryâs Gone Crackers Original: Key ingredients include brown rice, quinoa, millet, sesame seeds, and sea salt. Two strengths are its high fiber content (â3âŻg per serving) and the clean, glutenâfree label. One weakness is the relatively high price point compared with mainstream crackers. Ideal for busy vegans seeking a portable, nutrientâdense snack. For a deeper brand comparison see Simple Mills vs Mary's Gone Crackers.
Simple Mills Almond Flour Crackers: Key ingredients include almond flour, oat fiber, pumpkin seed meal, chia seeds, and olive oil. Two strengths are the low netâcarb profile (â5âŻg) and the buttery, satisfying crunch. One weakness is the shorter shelf life once opened, requiring refrigeration. Ideal for ketoâoriented eaters who crave a grainâfree alternative.
Simple Mills Seed & Grain Crackers: Key ingredients include sunflower seeds, pumpkin seeds, flaxseed, oats, and sea salt. Two strengths are the balanced proteinâtoâfiber ratio and the versatile flavor that pairs well with spreads. One weakness is the presence of added cane sugar for a mild sweetness. Ideal for families looking for an everyday snack that delivers steady energy.
Recipes and Kitchen Uses
Recipe 1: Crunchy Veggie Mini Pizzas
Ingredients:
- 4âŻĂâŻMaryâs Gone Crackers Original (large)
- 2âŻTbsp hummus (any flavor)
- ½âŻcup cherry tomatoes, halved
- ÂźâŻcup shredded mozzarella cheese
- 1âŻTbsp fresh basil, chopped
Instructions:
- Spread ½âŻTbsp hummus on each cracker as the base sauce.
- Top with cherry tomato halves, sprinkle mozzarella, and finish with basil.
- Place under a broiler for 2â3âŻminutes until cheese melts.
Prep time: 10 minutes.
Recipe 2: Simple Mills Seed & Grain Cracker Crusted Salmon
Ingredients:
- 2âŻfillets salmon (â150âŻg each)
- ½âŻcup Simple Mills Seed & Grain Crackers, finely crushed
- 1âŻTbsp olive oil
- ÂźâŻtsp smoked paprika
- Salt and pepper to taste
Instructions:
- Preheat oven to 200âŻÂ°C (400âŻÂ°F). Press crushed crackers onto each salmon fillet, drizzle with olive oil, and season with paprika, salt, and pepper.
- Transfer to a parchmentâlined baking sheet and bake for 12â15âŻminutes, until the crust is golden and the salmon flakes easily.
Prep time: 20 minutes.
Sustainability and Environmental Impact
Both brands prioritize responsible sourcing, but they differ in packaging footprints. Maryâs Gone Crackers uses recyclable kraft paper boxes with minimal plastic, reducing landfill waste. Simple Mills opts for compostable plantâbased sleeves but still incorporates a thin inner foil for freshness, which can be harder to recycle. Consumers can lower impact by buying in bulk, repurposing containers, and choosing products with certified organic grains that support regenerative agriculture.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Maryâs Gone Crackers truly glutenâfree?
Yes, Maryâs Gone Crackers are certified glutenâfree, with production facilities that follow strict crossâcontamination protocols, making them safe for celiac disease patients.
Which brand offers more protein per serving?
Simple Mills Seed & Grain Crackers provide about 5âŻg of protein per serving, compared to roughly 3âŻg in Maryâs Gone Crackers, making Simple Mills the higherâprotein option.
Can these crackers fit into a keto diet?
Simple Mills Almond Flour
Crackers are specifically formulated for lowâcarb, ketoâfriendly eating, while Maryâs Gone Crackers contain more carbs from whole grains, which may exceed strict keto limits.
Final Verdict
When weighing nutrition, texture, and price, Maryâs Gone Crackers excel in fiber density and clean ingredient transparency, whereas Simple Mills shines for lowâcarb and highâprotein needs. Snackers focused on wholeâgrain benefits may gravitate toward Maryâs, while keto or paleo adherents will likely prefer Simple Millsâ almondâbased line. Both brands deliver quality, but the choice hinges on dietary goals and budget constraints.
FoodReveal helps you decode nutrition labels beyond marketing. Available for Android and iOS.

